loading
insurance is required to pay for hospital stay after surgery

US Panel Mulls Minimum Breast Cancer Hospital Stay

Does insurance have to pay for hospital stay after breast cancer surgery?

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – A congressional panel on Wednesday said it has bipartisan support for a bill requiring health insurers to pay for a minimum 48-hour hospital stay after breast cancer treatment, to combat what critics call “drive-through” surgeries.

About 20 U.S. states have such a minimum insurance requirement for women undergoing mastectomies or lumpectomies to treat breast cancer. Advocates of the bill say federal legislation is needed to equalize coverage across the nation.

“Having access to appropriate medical care should not be dependent on the state you live in,” said Rep. Frank Pallone, the New Jersey Democrat who chairs the health subcommittee of the Energy and Commerce Committee.

Breast cancer is the most common form of cancer among women after skin cancer, killing more than 41,000 women a year in the United States, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

The bill has bipartisan support and 219 co-sponsors in the House of Representatives. A companion bill in the Senate has 19 co-sponsors thus far.

Women with breast cancer often undergo a mastectomy, in which the entire breast is completely removed, or a lumpectomy, a less drastic surgery that is followed by radiation therapy. About two-thirds of the 125,000 women who undergo mastectomies in the U.S. annually leave the hospital a few hours after surgery, without regard to their health, because their insurance will not pay for a longer stay, according to testimony from Dr. Kristen Zarfos, a fellow at the American College of Surgeons.

But America’s Health Insurance Plans, an industry group for most major health plans such as UnitedHealth Group and WellPoint Inc , called the bill unnecessary. “We do not think that it is a good idea on the state level or the federal level to be putting clinical guidelines into statute,” group spokeswoman Susan Pisano said.

Most health insurers treat each case on a “medical necessity” basis. “We think there are women who are satisfied with shorter lengths of stay,” she said.

DISEASE WINNERS AND LOSERS

Singer-songwriter and breast cancer survivor Sheryl Crow also testified at the House panel’s hearing, expressing support for a second bill that would provide $40 million annually for five years for federal research into environmental factors linked to breast cancer.

“There is little financial incentive for anyone else to do this research,” Crow told lawmakers. She added: “I have no idea why I got breast cancer or what I can say to others on how to prevent it.”

Some Republicans and a federal health official said the research bill would tie the government’s hands and interfere with science.

“In general, prescribing a specific way of conducting federal research could have the unintended consequence of narrowing the field of inquiry and promoting an unwise use of precious resources,” said Deborah Winn, associate director of epidemiology and genetics at the National Cancer Institute.

Because the bill establishes a panel to set research priorities, it could hamper current efforts, Winn said.

A Senate companion bill includes changes related to the peer review process that could make a compromise possible, Winn said.

The committee’s top Republican, Rep. Joe Barton of Texas, said he is worried that Congress is too susceptible to the power of disease groups.

For example, advocates for breast cancer are among the most organized and best funded advocacy groups, Barton said. If Congress responded to their entreaties, it would be “picking winners and losers in terms of who gets the most research. Where does that leave liver cancer? … What about autism …diabetes?” he asked.

Lifetime Television has put this bill on their Web page with a petition drive to show support. Last year over half the House signed on. To show your support, please click on the link below. If you choose to sign the petition you will not need to give more than your name, state, and zip code.

Lifetime TV breast cancer petition – support the bill at https://www.lifetimetv.com/breastcancer/petition/signpetition.php.

A congressional panel on Wednesday said it has bipartisan support for a bill requiring health insurers to pay for a minimum 48-hour hospital stay after breast cancer treatment, to combat what critics call “drive-through” surgeries.

Sign Up for Our Monthly Newsletter

Online Form – Newsletter Signup

Related News & Press

insurance is required to pay for hospital stay after surgery

US Panel Mulls Minimum Breast Cancer Hospital Stay

Fat-Derived Stem Cell Enhanced Breast Reconstruction for Lumpectomy Repair Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Cytori Celution Improves Soft Tissue Transplantation A lumpectomy is less drastic than having a mastectomy, but it leaves you with a scar and a dimple where a smooth, full curve used to be. The breast can also end up much smaller […]

Read More

surgical options for symmetry after lumpectomy

Fat-Derived Stem Cell Enhanced Breast Reconstruction for Lumpectomy Repair

Fat-Derived Stem Cell Enhanced Breast Reconstruction for Lumpectomy Repair Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Cytori Celution Improves Soft Tissue Transplantation A lumpectomy is less drastic than having a mastectomy, but it leaves you with a scar and a dimple where a smooth, full curve used to be. The breast can also end up much smaller […]

Read More

surgical options for symmetry after lumpectomy

Breast Reconstruction Advances Fix Distortions Left by Lumpectomy

Breast Reconstruction Advances Fix Distortions Left by Lumpectomy Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Are there breast reconstruction options to fix Lumpectomy defects? ASPS Report Examines Reconstruction Innovations for Breast Cancer Patients Including Partial and Full Mastectomies For Immediate Release: April 2008 ARLINGTON HEIGHTS, Ill.: Lumpectomy or breast conservation surgery is the most common type of […]

Read More

restore feeling after mastectomy prma plastic surgery

DIEP Flap Reconstruction And Breast Cancer Recurrence

DIEP Flap Reconstruction And Breast Cancer Recurrence Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Can DIEP flap breast reconstruction prevent the detection of breast cancer recurrence?  This is a very important issue that is often not discussed. A handful of studies have shown that breast reconstruction (with any reconstructive technique) does not impact local recurrence or long […]

Read More

more women would choose breast reconstruction if they knew it was an option

Breast Reconstruction Often Not Discussed

Breast Reconstruction Often Not Discussed Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Women with breast cancer faced with treatment decisions are often not told by their surgeons about the possibility of breast reconstruction after a mastectomy, a study confirms. When these conversations do occur, many more women choose mastectomy, researchers found. In a survey of 1,178 women […]

Read More

​Few Women Have Regrets When Choosing Preventive Mastectomy for Other Breast

​Few Women Have Regrets When Choosing Preventive Mastectomy for Other Breast Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Should you have a preventative mastectomy on the non-affected breast to reduce your risk of breast cancer?  Is this for me? If you have been diagnosed with breast cancer in one breast and are considering having the other breast […]

Read More

DIEP Flap Surgery And How To Find A DIEP Surgeon

DIEP Flap Surgery And How To Find A DIEP Surgeon Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin How can I find a DIEP flap breast reconstruction surgeon? Meet PRMA’s award winning DIEP flap surgeons DIEP flap surgery – so why all the hype? If you are a woman facing mastectomy due to breast cancer, one of the decisions […]

Read More

Patients Report Improved Quality of Life After DIEP Flap Breast Reconstruction

Patients Report Improved Quality of Life After DIEP Flap Breast Reconstruction June 15, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Heading2 sed ut perspiciatis unde omnis iste natus Far far away, behind the word mountains, far from the countries Vokalia. Far far away, behind the word mountains, far from the countries Vokalia. Far far away, behind […]

Read More

Breast Reconstruction Message Boards, Groups & Forums

Breast Reconstruction Message Boards, Groups & Forums June 15, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Heading2 sed ut perspiciatis unde omnis iste natus Far far away, behind the word mountains, far from the countries Vokalia. Far far away, behind the word mountains, far from the countries Vokalia. Far far away, behind the word mountains, far […]

Read More

post-img
Prev post

Fat-Derived Stem Cell Enhanced Breast Reconstruction for Lumpectomy Repair

Next post

Previous Abdominal Surgeries Increase Risk of Abdominal Complications after DIEP Flap Surgery

post-img
Subscribe Newsletter