Implant VS “Flap” Breast Reconstruction: Patient Reported Outcomes from Thin and Obese Patients
Does weight impact quality of life and satisfaction rates after “flap” breast reconstruction?
Patients today have many options to consider for breast reconstruction following a mastectomy. Reconstruction options include implants and microsurgical “flap” procedures like the DIEP flap.
All options can provide patients with good results. However, it is important for patients to be fully informed of ALL options prior to reconstruction and the pros and cons of each so they can make an informed decision on which procedure is best for them based on their lifestyle and outcome expectations.
Studies show that patients undergoing microsurgical “flap” based breast reconstruction have higher long-term satisfaction rates compared with those undergoing implant reconstruction. This type of research is an excellent reference for patients considering breast reconstruction after mastectomy. Adding long-term studies with patient reported outcomes adds another import element for surgeons and patients to discuss when weighing all options.
Two studies further analyze patient reported satisfaction and quality of life rankings of implant and “flap” procedures based on patient’s weight classifications.
The first study was conducted in 2015 and focused on thinner patients. The research showed that microsurgical breast reconstruction options can provide higher satisfactory results for thin patients compared to implant surgery. However, the study did show that more secondary revision surgeries and fat grafting were necessary to achieve the best results.
The second study was conducted in 2019 and focused on patients with obesity. Obesity has been shown to increase post-surgery complications in both microsurgical “flap” and implant reconstruction procedures. Regardless, the study results show “flap” reconstruction produces higher patient reported satisfaction results compared to implant reconstruction.
The results of these two weight specific studies are further evidence that “flap” procedures (like the DIEP flap) are excellent options for patients to consider regardless of their weight classification.
Further Reading Recommendations:
What is the difference between implant and flap breast reconstruction procedures?
What breast reconstruction procedure has the easiest recovery?
Why do patients choose DIEP flap reconstruction over implants?
Author: Dr. Minas Chrysopoulo and Courtney Floyd
All options can provide patients with good results. However, it is important for patients to be fully informed of ALL options prior to reconstruction and the pros and cons of each so they can make an informed decision on which procedure is best for them based on their lifestyle and outcome expectations.
Leave Comment
Sign Up for Our Monthly Newsletter
Continue Reading
Breast Reconstruction Surgery and Your Period
Breast Reconstruction Surgery and Your Period December 02, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin During our pre-operative appointment with patients, a topic that occasionally arises is menstrual cycles. It is completely normal for women to experience changes with their periods throughout breast cancer treatments. These can be temporary or permanent. Periods can be unpredictable following […]
What Bras and Abdominal Girdles to Wear After Breast Reconstruction Surgery
What Bras and Abdominal Girdles to Wear After Breast Reconstruction Surgery November 17, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin When preparing for breast reconstruction surgery, many patients want to know what types of bras and abdominal girdles they should plan to wear after surgery. Although every surgeon has slightly different preferences, we have put together […]
My 5 DIEP Flap Realities | A Guest Blog From Julie
My 5 DIEP Flap Realities October 28, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Hi everyone, my name is Julie from It’s a Bosom Thing. I am so happy to be here as a guest blogger and have this opportunity to share with you a few thoughts about life after DIEP Flap Surgery. I was diagnosed […]
PRMA’s BRA Day Virtual Event Recap
PRMA’s BRA Day Virtual Event Recap September 08, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Yesterday we celebrated Breast Reconstruction Awareness day! Although we missed seeing everyone in person this year, we were still able to spread education and awareness on ALL reconstructive options through our virtual efforts. We were also able to share information on […]
Second Stage DIEP Flap Surgery
Second Stage DIEP Flap Surgery September 08, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin DIEP flap breast reconstruction is typically comprised of at least two stages for the best outcomes. The second stage of surgery is commonly referred to as the “revision” stage and is usually performed about three months after the initial reconstruction. The purpose […]
If ‘Flaps’ Are Such A Great Breast Reconstruction Option, Why Doesn’t Everyone Get Them?
If ‘Flaps’ Are Such A Great Breast Reconstruction Option, Why Doesn’t Everyone Get Them? September 08, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Flap-based breast reconstruction procedures, like the DIEP flap, offer patients a safe, natural implant-alternative option to reconstruction after a mastectomy. Flap surgeries are permanent and are associated with fewer complications after radiation when […]
What is a Skin Island and How is it Used in Breast Reconstruction?
What is a Skin Island and How is it Used in Breast Reconstruction? September 08, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin What is a “skin island”? The term “skin island” is used to describe the remaining visible skin from a transplanted “flap” of tissue. In the setting of DIEP flap breast reconstruction, the skin island […]
Comparing APEX Flap and DIEP Flap Breast Reconstruction
Comparing APEX Flap and DIEP Flap Breast Reconstruction August 10, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin We have been receiving numerous inquiries about the “APEX flap” recently. Patients want to know what it is and how it differs from the DIEP flap. APEX is an acronym that stands for “Abdominal Perforator Exchange”. Many patients believe […]
Monitoring the Health of Your Flap During & After Surgery
Monitoring the Health of Your Flap During & After Surgery July 21, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin Autologous flap (or tissue) breast reconstruction procedures represent today’s most advanced options for rebuilding a breast(s) following mastectomy. The most commonly performed method of flap-based reconstruction at PRMA is the DIEP flap. During this procedure, surgeons transplant skin […]
COVID-19 and the Impact on Cancer Patient’s Mortality
COVID-19 and the Impact on Cancer Patient’s Mortality July 21, 2020 Share on Facebook Twitter Linkedin There is still so much we do not know about COVID-19. Likewise, there is little known about how this disease impacts mortality for cancer patients. A study published in The Lancet evaluated and characterized the outcomes of patients with cancer […]
No Comments